Overwatch 2 is a competent hero shooter undermined by the controversial circumstances of its creation. The core gameplay remains excellent -- hero abilities interact in creative ways, team composition matters deeply, and the shift to 5v5 has made matches faster and more individually impactful. The hero roster is diverse and well-designed, with new additions like Kiriko and Ramattra fitting naturally into the ecosystem. Cross-platform play broadens the player base significantly. However, the free-to-play transition came at a steep cost. The battle pass monetization replaced the original's generous loot box system with aggressive premium pricing for skins. New heroes locked behind the battle pass created pay-to-win concerns. The cancelled PvE mode -- a core selling point of the sequel -- represents one of gaming's most high-profile broken promises. The result is a game that plays very well but leaves a bitter taste, as players lost access to the original Overwatch and received a monetization-heavy update rebranded as a sequel. The gameplay deserves better than the business model surrounding it.